Social welfare: Ombudsperson Achitz criticises reduced benefits for children and persons entitled to asylum

Alongside a number of improvements – for example, for single parents and persons with disabilities – the amendment to the Social Welfare Fundamental Act (Sozialhilfe-Grundsatzgesetz) also includes a number of points that, at the very least, must be viewed with great scepticism. This is evident from a statement of opinion issued by the Austrian Ombudsman Board as part of the ongoing consultation process. Ombudsperson Bernhard Achitz, who is competent for the area of social welfare and the needs-based minimum benefit system, said: “The draft bill carries the risk that access to social welfare will be made more difficult or even impossible for those who need it most urgently.”

Every year, hundreds of people lodge complaints with the Austrian Ombudsman Board regarding social welfare or the needs-based minimum benefit system. For them, this financial support is absolutely vital. The new law also explicitly sets out the combating and prevention of poverty and social exclusion as its objective. “The Constitutional Court of Austria has also emphasised on several occasions that the social welfare system must fulfil its purpose of preventing and combating social hardship,” says Achitz. “Against this background, the Austrian Ombudsman Board recommends that, before any decision is taken (...), a thorough investigation be carried out once again to ascertain whether the proposed benefit cuts can, in the light of the court rulings of the independent judiciary, actually be regarded as constitutional,” states the Austrian Ombudsman Board’s statement of opinion verbatim.

Declining child benefits are incomprehensible

Achitz also criticises the fact that social welfare – and, above all, child allowances – will continue to be neither regulated uniformly across Austria nor justified in a comprehensible manner. The degressively scaled ‘corridor for child benefits’ provided for in the draft does not provide for a comprehensible assessment of realistically incurred costs. According to the statement of opinion, the Austrian Ombudsman Board cannot see “why, particularly in the case of families with multiple children, the additional costs per child should be reduced by more than half in reality, specifically between the fourth and fifth (or any subsequent) child.” In Vienna in particular, where most people reliant on social welfare live, this would represent a significant cut in benefits. Achitz: “It is also interesting that social welfare is set to decrease with each child, whilst family allowance increases for each additional child.”

Can 861 euros in social welfare guarantee the minimum existence level?

According to a statement of opinion by the Austrian Ombudsman Board, it is also “not without constitutional issues” that, for example, persons entitled to asylum and third-country nationals are to receive only 861 euros for at least four months. It is “hard to see how people can actually make ends meet on such a small amount, which in turn raises the question of whether the relevant provision really fulfils the purpose of guaranteeing the minimum existence level for the group of persons concerned.” Furthermore, “in the light of the court rulings of the Constitutional Court of Austria, it is doubtful whether the length of stay in Austria can constitute an objective criterion for differentiating the level of social assistance benefits”.

Improvements, including for persons with disabilities

However, the draft also provides for a number of improvements, such as mandatory supplements for single parents, and the fact that persons with disabilities living in an assisted group home are no longer regarded as a ‘benefit community’. Achitz: “At present, they also have to disclose the incomes of their flatmates, which complicates the application process.” Under the new draft bill, they are exempt from being regarded as a ‘household community’. It is also to be welcomed that, according to the draft, persons with disabilities over the age of 25 will no longer have to sue their parents for maintenance before they are entitled to social welfare.


Translation was AI-generated

Ombudsperson Bernhard Achitz in the Portico of Parliament The Austrian Ombudsman Board has sent a statement of opinion to Parliament regarding the Social Welfare Fundamental Act (Sozialhilfe-Grundsatzgesetz): Investigate whether it complies with the Constitution! (Picture: Ombudsperson Bernhard Achitz in the Portico of Parliament, photo by Paul Gruber)